Ask Scooby Bodybuilding Forum
March 18, 2010, 12:30:31 AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
News: Can't do a single pull-up? Time to conquer them for good!
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register Chat  
Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Down
  Print  
Author Topic: Women Can't Build Muscle?  (Read 1651 times)
ozmuz
Bulking Gnome
***

Reputation Power: 10
ozmuz has been heard.ozmuz has been heard.
Posts: 986


  • Awards Given for tirelessly and competently discussing and answering questions.

  • View Profile Awards
    « Reply #15 on: August 17, 2009, 06:53:22 PM »

    Quite well put DDB, Back in early `80`s I visited a gym with a friend for an intro workout, 2 girls came in who were well known, my wife actually did athletics with them. we took no notice until Bev and Gail started to outlift all of us guys in the gym. Gail was bigger and was a shot puter, but they really did not have standout muscles. Later Bev did BB and went to the states, don`t know what she took but many guys wanted muscle like hers, at that time it got popular but wasn`t natural (to me anyway) I`m glad its gone back to figure and nice shapes. Even guys that take testosterone find it hard to keep up as the body starts to balance by producing more esterone (female harmone), as I have read. Women who take testosterone also develope a deeper voice, some, facial and chest hair as well as enlarged parts of their genital system. So yeah women like nice as women but some may not be happy that way Smiley

    Bev before she got bigger
    Bev Francis Posing Routine in Pumping Iron 2DQ
    Logged

    Currently: chest 48in, arms 18in,14.5 BF 198lb, 5`5, next time here 185@10%

    Enjoy life..you only get one shot
    Goldie
    Global Moderator
    Übergnome
    *****

    Reputation Power: 35
    Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.
    Posts: 3356



    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #16 on: August 17, 2009, 07:52:16 PM »

    Sorry, but IMO that's ugly! I'd never want to look like that!
    Logged

    Wag more, bark less.
    Uglok
    Übergnome
    ****

    Reputation Power: 23
    Uglok is accepted.Uglok is accepted.Uglok is accepted.Uglok is accepted.
    Posts: 2014

  • Awards Given for tirelessly and competently discussing and answering questions. Given for excellent postings explaining ideas and concepts.

  • View Profile Awards
    « Reply #17 on: August 18, 2009, 01:35:44 AM »

    Sorry, but IMO that's ugly! I'd never want to look like that!

    Loss of femininity. Which is the basis of my half-finished-draft-long-awaited-post! lol
    Logged

    ~ Uglok ~
    Goal: Squat 150kg
    PB: 7x120kg on 17/7/09

    Routine/Diary   

    http://scoobysworkshop.com/simplemachinesforum/index.php?topic=768.0 will answer 1/2 your questions!
    Mind Axis
    Regular Gnome
    **

    Reputation Power: 5
    Mind Axis is starting out.
    Posts: 348


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #18 on: August 18, 2009, 04:01:30 AM »

    Good points. Keep in mind, there are a lot of women that aren't physically attractive to most people whether they pick up a weight or not, and the same goes with guys.

    Ugly and attractive are whats called relative terms. They're just opinions and they vary from person to person, according to circumstance and position in life. Some rhetorical questions to consider before making a decision about someone’s opinion on someone they think is beautiful: If I say that girl #17 (no particular significance to the number) is attractive, but you disagree, does that cause you to think that I am wrong? The superficial answer is of course no. But the immediate reaction is different. And if I say that girl #17 is attractive, do I think that all women should be attractive in the same manner? Let’s say that I do. Would it make any difference if I told you that I don’t expect them to be?

    A guy might say that the girl in one of these videos is hott...but something else to consider before you make your judgment is, exactly how hott does he think she is? Most guys do not think in terms of proportion, but that is exactly how they operate, and on top of this, they are attracted to more than one girl at any given moment.
     
    People can be very picky about who they would want to see themselves with...and some of them give themselves a lot more room to be picky than they can afford. Truth be told, and more often than not, the person they are judging is more attractive than they are! If I am a guy who happens to be relatively unattractive, and I say that some girl is unattractive, who is actually more attractive than I am, then I am arguing for justice on the wrong side of the fence! Hellooooo…Wake up Decepticons!! In other words if you are a guy who is 60 lbs overweight, or is just way too old, you canNOT and are NOT allowed to say that britney spears is unattractive. Why? Because YOU are at least TWICE as ugly!!!And truth be told, most people over-estimate themselves anyway even if they themselves are unattractive...And for a fair enough reason I suppose…nobody wants to consider themselves as unattractive. They don't know however, that beauty is a term that they are entirely too foreign to and that is why they suffer the way they do, comparing themselves to someone else all the time, judging themselves so harshly.  Nowadays if you are not attractive, either physically, socially, or in any way shape or form, you are thrown to the side of the street like a menstrual rag. I can pretty much guarantee that any one of you would be very quickly humbled by your own opinion, if, following this discussion, we were all individually whisked away by some mystical force, to a deserted island, every person to his/her own island, with only one other person to share it with, who is of the opposite sex, and is by the way, extremely unattractive. All of a sudden, your opinion changes and you are not so picky. With an undefined lapse of time, she even becomes attractive and desirable. That woman who lifted too many weights, and added too much testosterone, and “decreased her femininity” starts looking very feminine and very attractive. Come on, be honest.
     
    Also, let’s say that every guy in this forum thinks that the women in these videos are unattractive. Well, who's to say that the women in the videos are so willing to date you? If a relationship depended upon only one out of the two participants’ opinions about the other, then you would  have a lot more authority in what you say about female bodybuilders...and female anything for that matter. Truth is, the other person has a say in whether she wants to be with you or not. And anyone will tell you that reciprocation is key in any relationsihp.

    And finally, where (and what for that matter), would you say is that line which a woman would cross in order to go from being ugly (as some would classify it) to beautiful?

    That’s a difficult question but let’s just say for simplicity’s sake, that any woman with a generally fit body can be classified as beautiful. If she is overweight, then she needs to slim up and then she can be classified as beautiful. Can she really? You do know that eventually her skin will wrinkle and eventually she will become old and unattractive right? Okay so any woman with a generally fit body, who is proportionally aged with her potential mate, can be classified as beautiful. Can she really? Sure any guy would like to sleep with any girl like this, but does that make her beautiful? Probably not, since the same guy who says she is beautiful, is also willing to sleep with just about any other female on the planet whether she is as beautiful as her or not. But I’ve heard the fool beg and plead and vow “But I would be willing to spend the rest of my life with her!! I love her!! She’s so beautiful!!” Would you now? That’s called presumption and the fool falls for it all the time. The fact is that sex gets old real fast within the confines of a relationship, and it gets even older after marriage. After a short lapse of time, the only thing that remains is that sour attitude of the girl whom the fool had pledged to live his life with for the rest of his, simply because she was beautiful to him in that fleeting moment. And likewise for the woman... all she has is that sour attitude of the man who had pledged to love her for all time. But she didn’t know that he was led on by her skin deep beauty like a 500 lb man in a grocery store without anything to guide him but his hunger. Though the marriage doesn't end in divorce, the continued allegiance to marital vows degenerates into a rite of passage between the two for mutual peace. Again, beauty is a foreign concept to people and that is why the relationships which are based upon a false concept of beauty fail, and that is why relationships which otherwise could be, are not.

    So, I’ve said my share for now I think…how about you guys tell me what beauty is…


    « Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 04:49:25 AM by Mind Axis » Logged
    Goldie
    Global Moderator
    Übergnome
    *****

    Reputation Power: 35
    Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.
    Posts: 3356



    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #19 on: August 18, 2009, 05:26:08 AM »

    Well... gee... all I did was say "IMO", in my opinion, she's ugly. Beauty/handsomeness is certainly a matter of personal opinion.

    Still expressing my personal opinion... There are some general (NOT universal) standards of what constitutes beauty/handsomeness. I believe it's based on survival of the human race--the ability to procreate.

    A woman who is extremely muscled and has low body fat percentage, or who is anorexic, will not be able to get pregnant--procreate. A certain amount of body fat is necessary to support a pregnancy and nurse a baby. So therefore, many (not all, maybe not even most) men will find those muscular/anorexic women unattractive on an instinctive basis. They won't be able to get pregnant and carry on the man's genetics.

    The same holds true for general standards of what constitutes a good looking man. A strong, proportional man appeals to many (not all, maybe not even most) women on an instinctive basis because it indicates he is a good hunter and protector, will be able to provide for the woman and the family, and father similarly strong children. This ensures the survival of that woman, her children, and the human race. A man who is overly muscular will need more food to sustain his size, perhaps putting the rest of the "tribe" at risk in times of food shortages.

    There are, of course, cultural slants on attractiveness, and society has a large impact on people's views and opinions.

    At least women don't have to have red buttocks like baboons to attract men ROFL!
    Logged

    Wag more, bark less.
    Mind Axis
    Regular Gnome
    **

    Reputation Power: 5
    Mind Axis is starting out.
    Posts: 348


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #20 on: August 18, 2009, 08:18:37 AM »

    Well you can be at east Goldie because I wasn't attacking your opinion. I was simply defending my own...

    Cool Check this one out ladies Cool She's saxxxzzzzy I don't care what people say Cool

    which was actually intended to encourage the women but i guess it kind of back fired on me...
    « Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 08:45:54 AM by Mind Axis » Logged
    DaFatBunny
    DaFatBunny
    Regular Gnome
    **

    Reputation Power: 2
    DaFatBunny is starting out.
    Posts: 174


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #21 on: September 02, 2009, 11:15:25 AM »

    ewwwww i think that the woman in that video looks more like a man than a lot of men
    Logged

    Goals: want to do by January 1, 2010
    1.  Defined lower abs to have a complete 6-Pack
    2.  Bench 250 lbs (presently a little over 200)
    3.  Squat 325 lbs (presently around 275)
    4.  Clean 200 lbs (currently around 175)
    5.  Run at least a 4. 5 40 yard dash (at a 4. 65)
    lampuiho
    Jr. Gnome
    *

    Reputation Power: 1
    lampuiho is starting out.
    Posts: 58


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #22 on: October 23, 2009, 08:40:53 AM »

    She didn't even look like a girl! Ugh!

    On top of being ugly, I'd guess that her body fat % is too low for her to be healthy. From what I've found in my research, women who get down to around 12% body fat (may vary a little depending on the woman) experience hormonal disturbances that could result in loss of periods and bone loss, and there's a chance they have eating disorders.

    I plan on dying when I'm over a 100 years old because my parachute didn't open. There's no way I would risk bone loss!
    If they get to body fat % that low healthily, I doubt there is any hormonal disturbances.
    Logged
    Mind Axis
    Regular Gnome
    **

    Reputation Power: 5
    Mind Axis is starting out.
    Posts: 348


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #23 on: October 29, 2009, 03:47:05 AM »

    lol are you guys still talking about this? I guess she does kind of look like a guy. I bet her face is pretty though...every now and then you find a tomboy who is really REALLY pretty.
    Logged
    Goldie
    Global Moderator
    Übergnome
    *****

    Reputation Power: 35
    Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.Goldie has a powerful will.
    Posts: 3356



    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #24 on: October 29, 2009, 06:58:26 AM »

    If they get to body fat % that low healthily, I doubt there is any hormonal disturbances.

    HOW they get their body fat that low isn't the issue; the hormone disturbances occur BECAUSE of the low body fat percentage.
    Logged

    Wag more, bark less.
    ATP38
    Applying Gnome


    Reputation Power: 1
    ATP38 is starting out.
    Posts: 2


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #25 on: November 05, 2009, 07:05:57 AM »

    Quote from: Mind Axis link=topic=2336. msg24330#msg24330 date=1250593290
    Good points.  Keep in mind, there are a lot of women that aren't physically attractive to most people whether they pick up a weight or not, and the same goes with guys.

    Ugly and attractive are whats called relative terms.  They're just opinions and they vary from person to person, according to circumstance and position in life.  Some rhetorical questions to consider before making a decision about someone’s opinion on someone they think is beautiful: If I say that girl #17 (no particular significance to the number) is attractive, but you disagree, does that cause you to think that I am wrong? The superficial answer is of course no.  But the immediate reaction is different.  And if I say that girl #17 is attractive, do I think that all women should be attractive in the same manner? Let’s say that I do.  Would it make any difference if I told you that I don’t expect them to be? . . .

    I know this post is old, but wanted to say (nice effort) to “Mind Axis” for trying to remove the bias and negativity surrounding some of the comments on women, beauty and physical fitness.

    I joined this forum b/c I really like Scooby’s site & have been following his work for almost 2 yrs.  But it’s a shame to find yet another fitness forum, where the topic of women’s bodies continues to be subverted with subjects of attractiveness /prettiness, etc and  “undercover” judgmental statements that have no significant impact on the art, sport or way of life in pursuing physical fitness and/or bodybuilding, let alone actually helping someone feel welcomed in using this site as a fitness resource.                 

    I didn’t think this was a dating site or a beauty forum, yet a forum on health and fitness/ body building for a variety of men & women.

    Some women ( & men) want more significant muscle development and some don’t.  Some women( & men) won’t be able to achieve the similar results anyway -even with the same goals, due to a variety of reasons including, drive/discipline, body-type, genetics, etc.  Muscle development as a novice or experienced bodybuilder is simply [b]NOT[/b] an easy feat for most.

    Let’s not get ahead of the game and assume that every woman is looking for the same physical outcome.  The topic of “Who finds who else attractive” is a very distracting topic and a ancient and tired one.   I hope this forum will eventually address the various fitness goals (& how to achieve them) for a diversity of women, versus promoting a parochial view.
    Logged
    Evilcyber
    Administrator
    Übergnome
    *****

    Reputation Power: 36
    Evilcyber has a powerful will.Evilcyber has a powerful will.Evilcyber has a powerful will.Evilcyber has a powerful will.Evilcyber has a powerful will.Evilcyber has a powerful will.Evilcyber has a powerful will.
    Posts: 2976



    View Profile WWW Awards
    « Reply #26 on: November 06, 2009, 06:49:01 AM »

    When a woman comes here asking how she can get the most strength or the biggest muscles possible, she will receive advice on how to do so. But the majority of women looking into fitness are looking for ways to enhance their feminine attributes, just as their male counterparts try to with their masculinity.
    Logged

    Okeanos
    Jr. Gnome
    *

    Reputation Power: 1
    Okeanos is starting out.
    Posts: 56


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #27 on: November 08, 2009, 12:44:02 PM »

    I have to admit, I have a pic of Bev Francis on the bedroom wall, as inspiration, however she was not quite as lean then as she is in that vid, so she still had more of a feminine look, plus she was younger which may also account for the change in overall appearance. Mind Axis (??) brought up a great point about people not necessarily being attractive and it having no bearing on weight training etc...a number of strength forums tend to see people overlook that view completely; it's something I will highlight in the future because I feel it's a very pertinent point.

    I'm fortunate to have one of those physiques where I can put on a percentage of muscle and not have stick thin arms, which I'm very pleased about, but I also don't want an overly muscley physique. My routine is geared toward making sure I get what I want from it, so it comes down mostly to just conditioning which seems to give me decent muslce and decent fat percentages, without me having to overwork the system. Itried splits, several times, but frankly they bore me...sad but true.

    But I do agree some men and women have a preconceived view as to how much or how little muscle a woman should have...in the same way that the majority of people think men should have a 6 pack, I guess...and that's just not how society works. When we see women who feel comfortable with lots of muscle we tend to think "butch", "masculine"...never "content", "healthy"...Of course, I strongly disagree with those that pump drugs to get the necessary hormonal alterations to gain the muscle and they do tend to look very manly, whereas those who take no substances of that nature tend to retain a higher degree of femininity (whether they be slightly masculine in their looks or not, since within both genders we also tend to find feminine men and masculine women and vice versa).

    But women can build a certain percentage of muscle, and I find it healthy, unlike looking at twig arms which actually makes me feel phsyically sick sometimes.
    « Last Edit: November 08, 2009, 01:43:47 PM by Okeanos » Logged
    arthurfoxshot
    Jr. Gnome
    *

    Reputation Power: 1
    arthurfoxshot is starting out.
    Posts: 85



    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #28 on: November 10, 2009, 10:02:07 AM »

    From what I've seen I agree with the staement that when it comes to lower body women can build as well as men. Theres a decent athlete in my school, she looks like a stick, but when she wears shorts you can see her legs are killer, calfs and quads bursting out yet her upperbody barely exists.

    Many guys are the complete opposite it to this including me, yah I got stick legs Grin
    Logged

    Goal :25 pullups, 50 fist pushups, 30 chin ups, 3 muscle up, 20 dips.

    At the moment: 16 pull ups    35 fist pushups  20 chins ups, 15 dips. 2 muscle ups
    Heyendo30
    Jr. Gnome
    *

    Reputation Power: 1
    Heyendo30 is starting out.
    Posts: 63


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #29 on: November 13, 2009, 10:23:12 AM »

    The reason men aren't attracted to anorectic girls/women and sort of "disgusted", is because of a natural instinct (not a reasoning the consciously do) that a women with such low bodyfat cannot carry out a pregnancy. Knowing that as a fact, I can further support Goldie's statements that such a low body fat % on a girl is not healthy regardlessly and can only do harm.

    For the same reasons mentioned above, (so as to go into the discussion about attraction) men are attracted to "fertility", and as such "feminine" characteristics. All characteristics which are "feminine" or "sexy" in the eyes of most men are indicators of health. Thus good genes and good chance of reproduction. As such, the majority of men are not attracted to female bodybuilders. I bet some are, but they are a minority. Attraction is different from guy to guy, but unless you are part of a minority and have some "fetish", the general indicators of attraction are "health" signs. Some abs on a woman are fine, and even sexy, but to the point at which they are feminine and "healthy". Athletic girls are attractive, even if different from the models/celebs. And you cannot deny that athletic girls are healthy.

    So women CAN naturally build muscle, in my understanding, although not to the extent a man can. But they CAN get quite buff naturally. But should they? If kept healthy, and they like it, why not?
    Most girls however probably dont want "manly" arms, and most guys dont want them to have them either.

    Anyway, awesome post dodo!
    Logged
    Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Up
      Print  
     
    Jump to:  

    Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.9 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines LLC | Sitemap Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!
    Page created in 0.431 seconds with 23 queries. (Pretty URLs adds 0.078s, 2q)